Ben Coats
Freebooter
1. defeat the bandits.
2. take the lady into the city where you just came
3. look for the guy she's looking for (ask the bartender)
4. rent a room for the night and come down stairs he'll be waiting (the girls boyfriend/fiancé)
5. they will ask you to escort them to another town. (mine was St. John to PR)
6. once there the fiancé will tell you to come to the store and meet his father who offers you the reward.